Player Rating
-
- Ninja
- Posts: 13004
- Joined: Apr 28, 2020
Player Rating
Player rating to see in what are players excel, to better understand why they win games! Can also be used as a rough guide about who to study for what skill.
Skills:
Macro
What is it: The ability to control economic units to gather right resources and build enough buildings to facilitate optimal unit production.
Quintessential player: Diarouga
Micro
What is it: The ability to control individual or small clusters of units for optimal damage output or damage control.
Quintessential player: H2O_
Tactics
What is it: The ability to move and position all your military positions that will result in optimal engagement during battles. Sense of timing of when units should be attacking and when they shouldn't.
Quintessential player: Aizamk
Strategy
What is it: Overall knowledge of what's possible in this game, knowing what strategy requires which strategy to counter it and adapting accordingly, and how to most optimally execute the build orders required.
Quintessential player: Blackstar_OP
Scouting
What is it: Early in the game, the ability to scout the map in a logical pattern which leads to optimal treasure creeping or stealing. Later in the game, the ability to use (redundant or special) units to find out what the opponent is doing at the time it matters.
Quintessential player: Mitoe
Raiding
What is it: The ability to raid effectively and how likely the player is to raid.
Quintessential player: KönigErik
APM
What is it: Actions per minute.
Quintessential player: Garja
Mentality:
Civ Depth
What is it: How many civs the player can play at a high level ('10+ civs = 5/5, 8+ civs = 4/5 etc)
Quintessential player: Nagayumi
Aggression
What is it: How likely the player is to be the one attacking constantly.
Quintessential player: Samwise12
Consistency
What is it: How likely a player is able to produce the same high level game play when it matters.
Quintessential player: LordRaphael
Tilt
What is it: How likely a player is to tilt [spoiler=spoiler](dis is joke sorry)[/spoiler]
Quintessential player: H2O_
Player Rating
Player: Blackstar_OP
Macro: 5/5
Micro: 4/5
Tactics: 4/5
Strategy: 5/5
Scouting: 4/5
Raiding: 3/5
APM: 4/5
Civ Depth: 5/5
Aggression: 4/5
Consistency: 5/5
Player: LordRaphael
Macro: 4/5
Micro: 4/5
Tactics: 4/5
Strategy: 4/5
Scouting: 4/5
Raiding: 3/5
APM: 5/5
Civ Depth: 3/5
Aggression: 2/5
Consistency: 5/5
Player: Kaiserklein
Macro: 4/5
Micro: 5/5
Tactics: 3/5
Strategy: 4/5
Scouting: 4/5
Raiding: 2/5
APM: 4/5
Civ Depth: 3/5
Aggression: 3/5
Consistency: 3/5
Player: Mitoe
Macro: 4/5
Micro: 4/5
Tactics: 4/5
Strategy: 4/5
Scouting: 5/5
Raiding: 3/5
APM: 4/5
Civ Depth: 4/5
Aggression: 2/5
Consistency: 2/5
Skills:
Macro
What is it: The ability to control economic units to gather right resources and build enough buildings to facilitate optimal unit production.
Quintessential player: Diarouga
Micro
What is it: The ability to control individual or small clusters of units for optimal damage output or damage control.
Quintessential player: H2O_
Tactics
What is it: The ability to move and position all your military positions that will result in optimal engagement during battles. Sense of timing of when units should be attacking and when they shouldn't.
Quintessential player: Aizamk
Strategy
What is it: Overall knowledge of what's possible in this game, knowing what strategy requires which strategy to counter it and adapting accordingly, and how to most optimally execute the build orders required.
Quintessential player: Blackstar_OP
Scouting
What is it: Early in the game, the ability to scout the map in a logical pattern which leads to optimal treasure creeping or stealing. Later in the game, the ability to use (redundant or special) units to find out what the opponent is doing at the time it matters.
Quintessential player: Mitoe
Raiding
What is it: The ability to raid effectively and how likely the player is to raid.
Quintessential player: KönigErik
APM
What is it: Actions per minute.
Quintessential player: Garja
Mentality:
Civ Depth
What is it: How many civs the player can play at a high level ('10+ civs = 5/5, 8+ civs = 4/5 etc)
Quintessential player: Nagayumi
Aggression
What is it: How likely the player is to be the one attacking constantly.
Quintessential player: Samwise12
Consistency
What is it: How likely a player is able to produce the same high level game play when it matters.
Quintessential player: LordRaphael
Tilt
What is it: How likely a player is to tilt [spoiler=spoiler](dis is joke sorry)[/spoiler]
Quintessential player: H2O_
Player Rating
Player: Blackstar_OP
Macro: 5/5
Micro: 4/5
Tactics: 4/5
Strategy: 5/5
Scouting: 4/5
Raiding: 3/5
APM: 4/5
Civ Depth: 5/5
Aggression: 4/5
Consistency: 5/5
Player: LordRaphael
Macro: 4/5
Micro: 4/5
Tactics: 4/5
Strategy: 4/5
Scouting: 4/5
Raiding: 3/5
APM: 5/5
Civ Depth: 3/5
Aggression: 2/5
Consistency: 5/5
Player: Kaiserklein
Macro: 4/5
Micro: 5/5
Tactics: 3/5
Strategy: 4/5
Scouting: 4/5
Raiding: 2/5
APM: 4/5
Civ Depth: 3/5
Aggression: 3/5
Consistency: 3/5
Player: Mitoe
Macro: 4/5
Micro: 4/5
Tactics: 4/5
Strategy: 4/5
Scouting: 5/5
Raiding: 3/5
APM: 4/5
Civ Depth: 4/5
Aggression: 2/5
Consistency: 2/5
-
- Skirmisher
- Posts: 160
- Joined: Jun 22, 2015
Re: Player Rating
No one can out APM the G!
I think you can rate them out of ten rather than five but this is fine.
You forgot to rate their tilt under the players as well
I think you can rate them out of ten rather than five but this is fine.
You forgot to rate their tilt under the players as well
Got Badger Milk?
Re: Player Rating
That's nice, I like these criteria and found each quintessential player to be very relevant. An overall rating would probably be needed
"Prestige is like a powerful magnet that warps even your beliefs about what you enjoy. If you want to make ambitious people waste their time on errands, bait the hook with prestige." - Paul Graham
Re: Player Rating
H2o's rating or diarouga's ?
- Imperial Noob
- Lancer
- Posts: 958
- Joined: Feb 29, 2016
- Location: Well hello DEre
Re: Player Rating
love this thread <3 when you finish all, I could make it nice and pretty in excel
-
- Ninja
- Posts: 13004
- Joined: Apr 28, 2020
Re: Player Rating
I'm not going to finish it all it's up to you guys to help!
- JakeyBoyTH
- Howdah
- Posts: 1744
- Joined: Oct 15, 2016
- ESO: Ex-Contributor
- Location: New Zealand
Re: Player Rating
fingolfin wrote:H2o's rating or diarouga's ?
You look familiar I think I have seen you before are you related to @Gendarme ?
Advanced Wonders suck
- Aizamk
Ugh Advanced Wonders suck
- Aizamk
- Aizamk
Ugh Advanced Wonders suck
- Aizamk
Re: Player Rating
I think blackstar is very good at raiding, tibia as well
-
- Ninja
- Posts: 13004
- Joined: Apr 28, 2020
Re: Player Rating
ye raiding was one i just kinda guessed. He's a teamplayer, so maybe it should be upped 1-2 rates. i think most top players have good quality raiding when they raid, but for some players its really a trademark part of their play. with erik, or irish for example.
Re: Player Rating
Nice ! I am a bit surprised by bsop raid only 3/5 and civ dept 5/5 ? Are you sure ?
Also, even if he doesn't raid a lot, kaiser's raids are often effectiv because he micro his uhlans perfectly to finish as many vils as possible each times, so a 2/5 seems a bit rude Imo.
I agree ti everyting else :-)
I try diarouga, considering I know him well :
Macro : 5/5
Micro : 4/5
Tactics : 5/5
Strategy : 5/5
Scouting : 3/5
Raiding : 2/5
APM : 4/5
Civ dept : 5/5
Agression : 0/5 diarouga prefers to defend, but that's not less efficient so I am not sure to understand this one
Consistancy : 4/5
Also, even if he doesn't raid a lot, kaiser's raids are often effectiv because he micro his uhlans perfectly to finish as many vils as possible each times, so a 2/5 seems a bit rude Imo.
I agree ti everyting else :-)
I try diarouga, considering I know him well :
Macro : 5/5
Micro : 4/5
Tactics : 5/5
Strategy : 5/5
Scouting : 3/5
Raiding : 2/5
APM : 4/5
Civ dept : 5/5
Agression : 0/5 diarouga prefers to defend, but that's not less efficient so I am not sure to understand this one
Consistancy : 4/5
-
- Ninja
- Posts: 13004
- Joined: Apr 28, 2020
Re: Player Rating
bwinner1 wrote:Nice ! I am a bit surprised by bsop raid only 3/5 and civ dept 5/5 ? Are you sure ?
Also, even if he doesn't raid a lot, kaiser's raids are often effectiv because he micro his uhlans perfectly to finish as many vils as possible each times, so a 2/5 seems a bit rude Imo.
I agree ti everyting else :-)
I try diarouga, considering I know him well :
Macro : 5/5
Micro : 4/5
Tactics : 5/5
Strategy : 5/5
Scouting : 3/5
Raiding : 2/5
APM : 4/5
Civ dept : 5/5
Agression : 0/5 diarouga prefers to defend, but that's not less efficient so I am not sure to understand this one
Consistancy : 4/5
as I explained in my previous post, its mostly about likelyhood to raid. Kaiser just barely ever raids, and he mains germany. He attacks with his first 7 uhlans, and after that he doesnt really raid in most his games. I think 2/5 is correct. The 3/5 for bsop might be 4/5. It's a bit hard to say, i was mostly judging it from his games vs rapha in the finals. And there werent that many raids iirc.
As for bsop civ depth, i think he plays about10 civs at high level (japan, india, sioux, all euro civs except spain). Maybe it's 4/5 instead and hes at 9. IT's not exact science lol. feel free to make your own rating for the same player.
- aligator92
- Howdah
- Posts: 1519
- Joined: Feb 27, 2015
- ESO: aligator92
Re: Player Rating
nice idea but how is Raphael the quintessential player for consistency but only scores 4/5 while BS scores 5/5?
- lemmings121
- Jaeger
- Posts: 2673
- Joined: Mar 15, 2015
- ESO: lemmings121
Re: Player Rating
interesting.
can we call this methodology the UR? (Umeu's Rating.)
-hey bro, whats your UR?
-how would you rate my UR?
can we call this methodology the UR? (Umeu's Rating.)
-hey bro, whats your UR?
-how would you rate my UR?
-
- Lancer
- Posts: 723
- Joined: Aug 8, 2016
- ESO: Marco1698
Re: Player Rating
Player Rating
Player: Kickass_OP
Macro: 6/5
Micro: 6/5
Tactics: 6/5
Strategy: 6/5
Scouting: 6/5
Raiding: 6/5
APM: 6/5
Civ Depth: 6/5
Aggression: 6/5
Consistency: 6/5
Happy?
Player: Kickass_OP
Macro: 6/5
Micro: 6/5
Tactics: 6/5
Strategy: 6/5
Scouting: 6/5
Raiding: 6/5
APM: 6/5
Civ Depth: 6/5
Aggression: 6/5
Consistency: 6/5
Happy?
Re: Player Rating
sorry but Dicktator is the best and his guides are great on youtube under conqueror999 why isnt he featured ? he beats almost all these players.
Re: Player Rating
zukapit wrote:sorry but Dicktator is the best and his guides are great on youtube under conqueror999 why isnt he featured ? he beats almost all these players.
Its for supermacy I think there must be different ways of estimating rating in treaty as the game different
-
- Ninja
- Posts: 13004
- Joined: Apr 28, 2020
Re: Player Rating
aligator92 wrote:nice idea but how is Raphael the quintessential player for consistency but only scores 4/5 while BS scores 5/5?
ye you're right about that. i guess i felt i had to put rapha somewhere. i mean there are more players for each category. perhaps rapha's consistency should be upped a bit. he has made 3 finals in 3 tournaments, thats pretty consistent. i rated it 4/5 because he does drop more games overall than let's say h2o or bsop on the road to the finals. but perhaps that's due to lack of civ depth or something else.
-
- Advanced Player
- Posts: 768
- Joined: Aug 7, 2016
- ESO: miggo1999
- Location: Hannover
Re: Player Rating
Nice thread, although I find, that the tilt -factor should be regarded as an actual point :F
-
- Ninja
- Posts: 14364
- Joined: Mar 26, 2015
Re: Player Rating
This is really fun. I like this a lot.
Re: Player Rating
Waterboarding
What is it: You know what it is.
Quintessential player: kynesie
What is it: You know what it is.
Quintessential player: kynesie
-
- Advanced Player
- Posts: 768
- Joined: Aug 7, 2016
- ESO: miggo1999
- Location: Hannover
Re: Player Rating
one cold boi can't Finnish a brazillian hottie with 3 cavsh
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 28 guests