Page 1 of 36
Japanese Discussion Thread
Posted: 30 Oct 2015, 18:55
by iNcog
This is the Japanese Discussion thread, where several topics concerning this civilization on the ESOC Patch may be discussed. We're looking for feedback on the current state of balance, from the community's standpoint.
Japanese Discussion Thread
Posted: 02 Nov 2015, 05:49
by à ¸ªà ¸¢à ¸²à ¸¡
japanese are op .because he have toshogu shrine and shrine (nerf toshogu shrine and shrine). nerf Golden Pavilion. he have Daimyo(general)can train units and shipment . but other civ don't have general. they have more shrine20 down to 10shrine. and nerf yumi have high damage can kill cavalry. and they have high Siege Damage. can 2 shipment at one card.
Japanese Discussion Thread
Posted: 02 Nov 2015, 05:54
by Marco1698
I think an overpowered civilization can win vs everything but they surely can't vs iro / Otto. They have a bad early game, that's why Russian Indian can punish them early. You can consider also, that wall are nerfed so it's really hard counter an all in rush at this point
Japanese Discussion Thread
Posted: 03 Nov 2015, 00:21
by MCJim
What about lowering the food income by their shines? Is questionable if they seem te be too OP.
Japanese Discussion Thread
Posted: 03 Nov 2015, 00:26
by deleted_user0
After wall nerf they should be ok.
Maybe reduce ashi speed to 4.
Japanese Discussion Thread
Posted: 03 Nov 2015, 10:48
by momuuu
I do not think Japan is even close to OP right now. They are a very strong civ though.
Japanese Discussion Thread
Posted: 03 Nov 2015, 11:22
by Marco1698
Nerf wall is enough imo
Japanese Discussion Thread
Posted: 03 Nov 2015, 11:28
by britishmusketeer
somppukunkku wrote:After wall nerf they should be ok.
Maybe reduce ashi speed to 4.
+1
Japanese Discussion Thread
Posted: 03 Nov 2015, 11:37
by Hazza54321
britishmusketeer wrote:somppukunkku wrote:After wall nerf they should be ok.
Maybe reduce ashi speed to 4.
+1
+2
Japanese Discussion Thread
Posted: 03 Nov 2015, 11:50
by yurashic
Iroquois and Ottomans were nerfed and don't win Japanese now. I would suggest nerfing ashigaru speed to 4 like others here say and buffing Yabusame significantly to make them viable and give Japanese a proper counter-artillery unit.
Japanese Discussion Thread
Posted: 03 Nov 2015, 11:56
by Mr_Bramboy
yurashic wrote:Iroquois and Ottomans were nerfed and don''t win Japanese now. I would suggest nerfing ashigaru speed to 4 like others here say and buffing Yabusame significantly to make them viable and give Japanese a proper counter-artillery unit.
Basically this. Japanese aren''t overpowered, but their units are kinda broken.
Japanese Discussion Thread
Posted: 03 Nov 2015, 12:02
by _DB_
Don't nerf Ashi speed, as it is the original idea behind the civilization. The patch was made to not destroy the original feature of the civilization.
Maybe nerf the shogun aura, daimyo aura and -5% from golden pavilion boost and the maybe nerf shrine's HP by 200 or 300.
Make 4 flamming arrows in age 4 cost 500 food each time they are sent. Make 14 ashis to 13 ashis, 16 yumis to 14 yumis.
Shogun tokugawa shipment should cost 500 food to be sent.
Japanese Discussion Thread
Posted: 03 Nov 2015, 12:25
by yurashic
subzero wrote:Don''t nerf Ashi speed, as it is the original idea behind the civilization. The patch was made to not destroy the original feature of the civilization.
Maybe nerf the shogun aura, daimyo aura and -5% from golden pavilion boost and the maybe nerf shrine''s HP by 200 or 300.
Make 4 flamming arrows in age 4 cost 500 food each time they are sent. Make 14 ashis to 13 ashis, 16 yumis to 14 yumis.
Shogun tokugawa shipment should cost 500 food to be sent.
Japanese industrial has already been nerfed hard.
Have fun getting raided by "the original feature of the civilization" and not being able to respond.
Japanese Discussion Thread
Posted: 03 Nov 2015, 12:29
by _DB_
yurashic wrote:subzero wrote:Dont nerf Ashi speed, as it is the original idea behind the civilization. The patch was made to not destroy the original feature of the civilization.
Maybe nerf the shogun aura, daimyo aura and -5% from golden pavilion boost and the maybe nerf shrines HP by 200 or 300.
Make 4 flamming arrows in age 4 cost 500 food each time they are sent. Make 14 ashis to 13 ashis, 16 yumis to 14 yumis.
Shogun tokugawa shipment should cost 500 food to be sent.
Japanese industrial has already been nerfed hard.
Have fun getting raided by "the original feature of the civilization" and not being able to respond.
I agree that the ashi speed is too OP feature and ashi raids are just too annoying. Unfortunately it is original feature and FP team is not gonna remove it, Im sure.
Japanese Discussion Thread
Posted: 03 Nov 2015, 12:29
by Marco1698
subzero wrote:Don''t nerf Ashi speed, as it is the original idea behind the civilization. The patch was made to not destroy the original feature of the civilization.
Maybe nerf the shogun aura, daimyo aura and -5% from golden pavilion boost and the maybe nerf shrine''s HP by 200 or 300.
Make 4 flamming arrows in age 4 cost 500 food each time they are sent. Make 14 ashis to 13 ashis, 16 yumis to 14 yumis.
Shogun tokugawa shipment should cost 500 food to be sent.
wtf, pls man jap are already ok.
Japanese Discussion Thread
Posted: 03 Nov 2015, 12:32
by [Armag] diarouga
Nerfing ashi's speed is a nice idea since that's an abusable mech but on the other hand, I'd like to see yabusames being nerfed because atm jap can't do much vs artillery.
Japanese Discussion Thread
Posted: 03 Nov 2015, 13:37
by Garja
Ashi speed is untouchable, it's like changing the range of lbows or the area damage of cuirs.
Japanese right now are a pretty balanced civ.
Japanese Discussion Thread
Posted: 03 Nov 2015, 14:14
by deleted_user0
garja wrote:Ashi speed is untouchable, it''s like removing changing the range of lbows or the area damage of cuirs.
Japanese right now are a pretty balanced civ.
Don''t even mention shitlongbows and ashigarus in the same sentence... Ashigarus still remain decent in age II and op in the later ages.
I''m still not sure do you usually play this game high or are you always just purposefully against most people.
Japanese Discussion Thread
Posted: 03 Nov 2015, 17:25
by [Armag] diarouga
Japan is balanced, most top players agree on that.
Japanese Discussion Thread
Posted: 03 Nov 2015, 17:47
by KINGofOsmane
marco1698 wrote:subzero wrote:Dont nerf Ashi speed, as it is the original idea behind the civilization. The patch was made to not destroy the original feature of the civilization.
Maybe nerf the shogun aura, daimyo aura and -5% from golden pavilion boost and the maybe nerf shrines HP by 200 or 300.
Make 4 flamming arrows in age 4 cost 500 food each time they are sent. Make 14 ashis to 13 ashis, 16 yumis to 14 yumis.
Shogun tokugawa shipment should cost 500 food to be sent.
wtf, pls man jap are already ok.
you drunk ?
Japanese Discussion Thread
Posted: 04 Nov 2015, 14:54
by Garja
somppukunkku wrote:garja wrote:Ashi speed is untouchable, its like removing changing the range of lbows or the area damage of cuirs.
Japanese right now are a pretty balanced civ.
Dont even mention shitlongbows and ashigarus in the same sentence... Ashigarus still remain decent in age II and op in the later ages.
Im still not sure do you usually play this game high or are you always just purposefully against most people.
Ashi cost a shit ton. Right now base ashi lose to base musketeer per cost.
Japanese Discussion Thread
Posted: 04 Nov 2015, 21:48
by deleted_user0
garja wrote:somppukunkku wrote:Dont even mention shitlongbows and ashigarus in the same sentence... Ashigarus still remain decent in age II and op in the later ages.
Im still not sure do you usually play this game high or are you always just purposefully against most people.
Ashi cost a shit ton. Right now base ashi lose to base musketeer per cost.
And in fortress? :hihihi:
Japanese Discussion Thread
Posted: 04 Nov 2015, 21:54
by Garja
And in fortress they're pretty good indeed, but I'm sure that's the case of many units. Actually musketeers in age3 lose quite some use because of skirms.
Japanese Discussion Thread
Posted: 05 Nov 2015, 01:14
by pikadasgalaxias
Sanctuary resources flow should be slightly lower. The shoguns must have a cost to be sent, about 700 food is something acceptable or decrease the power of his aura.
Japanese Discussion Thread
Posted: 05 Nov 2015, 01:18
by fei123456
how to beat japan on siberia? with euro civs like france. their eco is insane.