Player Rating - Treaty Version

[Gichtenlord]

That doesnt look accurate to me...
Player: dicktator_
Macro - Res: 5/5
Micro: 4/5
Tactics: 4.5/5
Strategy - Matchup Knowledge: 4/5
Strategy - Map Control/Map Use: 4/5
Macro - Production: 5/5
APM: 4.5/5
Civ depth: 5/5
Consistency: 4/5
Endurance: 5/5
Dicktator is the best when it comes to managing resources, keeping pop up and bouncing back if he is on low eco and cant keep up 200 pop anymore.
On the other side, besides culv control, he is lacking finer unit micro. For example floko is better than nick in sniping/pressuring opponents artillery with skirms and nats. Also, nick sometimes tries to force his playstyle in a match up in which it is not the best (Lukas excelling in that aspect). Lastly, he is very predictable and quite passive when it comes to map control

[Googol]

@Gichtenlord rate me

[Gichtenlord]

@Gichtenlord rate me

Macro - Res: 2/5
Micro: 2/5
Tactics: 2/5
Strategy - Matchup Knowledge: 2/5
Strategy - Map Control/Map Use: 2/5
Macro - Production: 2/5
APM: 2/5
Civ depth: 2/5
Consistency: 2/5
Endurance: 2/5
top 32 treaty player

[Googol]

@Gichtenlord rate me

Macro - Res: 2/5
Micro: 2/5
Tactics: 2/5
Strategy - Matchup Knowledge: 2/5
Strategy - Map Control/Map Use: 2/5
Macro - Production: 2/5
APM: 2/5
Civ depth: 2/5
Consistency: 2/5
Endurance: 2/5
top 32 treaty player

@tedere12 yes !

[dicktator_]

Dicktator is the best

You should've just stopped there.





Nah I'm kidding your lost is pretty accurate. Now we just need a fair, unbiased rating of @sergyou (I elect @Sabusa for this task).

[Cometk]

Sergyou7
Macro - Res: 3.5/5
Micro: 3/5
Tactics: 3/5
Strategy - Matchup Knowledge: 3.5/5
Strategy - Map Control/Map Use: 3.5/5
Macro - Production: 3/5
APM: 3/5
Civ depth: 3.5/5
Consistency: 3.5/5
Endurance: 4/5

Gichtenlord
Macro - Res: 4/5
Micro: 4/5
Tactics: 5/5*
Strategy - Matchup Knowledge: 5/5
Strategy - Map Control/Map Use: 4/5
Macro - Production: 4/5*
APM: 4/5
Civ depth: 4.5/5
Consistency: 4/5
Endurance: 4/5

but i haven't seen gich play in a while, or that much first person
*dicktator edits

[Cometk]

gonna rate myself too so none of you fucks bastardize me
Macro - Res: 3.5/5
Micro: 4/5
Tactics: 4/5
Strategy - Matchup Knowledge: 4/5
Strategy - Map Control/Map Use: 3.5/5
Macro - Production: 3.5/5
APM: 4/5
Civ depth: 5/5
Consistency: 3.5/5
Endurance: 2.5/5

[Gichtenlord]

Thats a very friendly rating of me
Sadly, Ive rarely seen u play trevor and you are even more inactive than me

[dicktator_]

For Gichtenlord, I'd notch up tactics to 4.5/5 or 5/5 (his forward walling was always very on point and stood out compared to other players, his unit positioning was usually good as well), while maybe dropping production to 4/5. Assuming we're talking about gich in his prime and not rusty gich.

[NyxAchlys9]

Player: CometK (Like the cereal but not special)
Macro - Res: 4/5
Micro: 4/5
Tactics: 4/5
Strategy - Matchup Knowledge: 4/5
Strategy - Map Control/Map Use: 3.69/5
Macro - Production: 3.75/5
APM: 4/5
Civ depth: 6/5
Consistency: 3.141592654/5
Endurance: 2.5/5

[dicktator_]

I wanted to rate zivearia but I don't think I've played him enough. I guess I'll try matt.
Player: Milky__
Macro - Res: 4/5
Micro: 3/5
Tactics: 3/5
Strategy - Matchup Knowledge: 4/5
Strategy - Map Control/Map Use: 4/5
Macro - Production: 3/5
APM: 4.5/5
Civ depth: 3/5 (A willingness to try new civs but his brits being clearly better)
Consistency: 3/5
Endurance: 4/5

[Gichtenlord]

Ziv is like super allround 3.5 - 4 in all stats probably. Dont be fooled by his apm spamming though

[sergyou]

Dicktator is the best

You should've just stopped there.





Nah I'm kidding your lost is pretty accurate. Now we just need a fair, unbiased rating of @sergyou (I elect @Sabusa for this task).

u can do it urself but i can already tell what is going to look like but since we are on it , do queen's

[InsectPoison]

Player: Storm_999_
Macro - Res: 3/5
Micro: 5/5
Tactics: 5/5
Strategy - Matchup Knowledge: 5/5
Strategy - Map Control/Map Use: 4/5
Macro - Production: 4/5
APM: 3/5
Civ depth: 4/5
Consistency: 4/5
Endurance: 4/5
Smurfing Lukas : 6/5

[dicktator_]

Player: Storm_999_
Macro - Res: 3/5
Micro: 5/5
Tactics: 5/5
Strategy - Matchup Knowledge: 5/5
Strategy - Map Control/Map Use: 4/5
Macro - Production: 4/5
APM: 3/5
Civ depth: 4/5
Consistency: 4/5
Endurance: 4/5
Smurfing Lukas : 6/5

Reduce his endurance a bit - he tended to resign early :p

Also imo - micro 4/5, tactics 4/5, production 5/5

[Gichtenlord]

Lul micro, lul match up knowledge, lul tactics, lul civ depth

[InsectPoison]

Lul micro, lul match up knowledge, lul tactics, lul civ depth

Give a proper argument instead of your useless shitposts.

[Cometk]

i would put micro to 3 and lower matchup knowledge and tactics, but raise civ depth, afaik he was pretty good with every civ

maybe keep tactics a 5 if u count ddos

[sebnan12]

Player: Fran999
Macro - Res: 4/5
Micro: 2/5
Tactics: Ports
Strategy - Matchup Knowledge: 5/5
Strategy - Map Control/Map Use: 5.1/5
Macro - Production: 3/5
APM: 3/5
Civ depth: 10/5
Consistency: 1.5/5
Endurance: 6/5
Knowledge about the exact range of Portuguese mortars: 5/5

[sebnan12]

Lul micro, lul match up knowledge, lul tactics, lul civ depth

Give a proper argument instead of your useless shitposts.

ok storm

[InsectPoison]

Player: _Pi
Macro - Res: 4/5
Micro: 3/5
Tactics: 5/5
Strategy - Matchup Knowledge: 5/5
Strategy - Map Control/Map Use: 4/5
Macro - Production: 4/5
APM: 3/5
Civ depth: 3/5
Consistency: 3/5
Endurance: 3/5

[Hazza54321]

Tactics: ports

[NyxAchlys9]

:hehe: Tactics: ports

[QueenOfdestiny]

And me?

[Gichtenlord]

Player: QueenOfDestiny
Macro: 2/5
Micro: 0.5/5
Tactics: 1/5
Strategy: 2/5
Scouting: 2/5
Raiding: 1/5
APM: 1/5
Civ Depth: 1/5
Aggression: 3/5
Consistency: 3/5
Tilt: 4.5/5

viewtopic.php?f=19&t=11920&start=75#p258551