Create a blacklist of (confirmed) cheaters.
- Mr_Bramboy
- Retired Contributor
- Posts: 8219
- Joined: Feb 26, 2015
- ESO: [VOC] Bram
- Location: Amsterdam
Create a blacklist of (confirmed) cheaters.
I just got dropped again and I''m honestly sick of it. I''ve suggested a similar blacklist before but never got a real answer back. My idea is to make a blacklist on the forums with a list of cheaters. I don''t want to have a witchhunt, I just want to make people aware of the fact that certain players are cheaters. Of course, there must be evidence (recorded footage of a dropper) which must be submitted to a moderator of the blacklist. It''d also be a good idea to lock the thread so that there won''t be random accusations without any evidence.
Thoughts? If this is well organized and not a total mess, I think it''d be a good idea.
And for those saying "just pest em lol", I mainly play quicksearch because I think you improve more from playing against random people with random ranks on random maps with random civs.
Thoughts? If this is well organized and not a total mess, I think it''d be a good idea.
And for those saying "just pest em lol", I mainly play quicksearch because I think you improve more from playing against random people with random ranks on random maps with random civs.
Create a blacklist of (confirmed) cheaters.
Better add (..) to that list huh. I don't know why they removed my posts? It was clear he cheated. Even he got pr / points on ELO rating with 104 vills made and 104 vills killed. He said he would drop, did drop, messaged me to laugh about it - all of this was screenshot, so why not leave on this forum?
Why is he still in the tournament able to play? Ban him. He's a proven cheater.
Why is he still in the tournament able to play? Ban him. He's a proven cheater.
-
- Skirmisher
- Posts: 135
- Joined: Mar 28, 2015
Create a blacklist of (confirmed) cheaters.
bhcata wrote:Better add (..) to that list huh. I don''t know why they removed my posts? It was clear he cheated. Even he got pr / points on ELO rating with 104 vills made and 104 vills killed. He said he would drop, did drop, messaged me to laugh about it - all of this was screenshot, so why not leave on this forum?
Why is he still in the tournament able to play? Ban him. He''s a proven cheater.
Even if i dont know him.. i dont thibk anyone who plays aoe is stupid enough to cheat in the tourney lol
Create a blacklist of (confirmed) cheaters.
That's not the point - the point is if you cheat outside of the tourney and it's proven (he was stupid enough to say he'll drop me, drop me, get the ELO, and then message me to take the piss that he dropped me), then they shouldnt be able to play in the tourney.
Create a blacklist of (confirmed) cheaters.
Have you tried reporting him? Its easier for them to ban people if they say that they are going to drop you, because then it's not possible that it actually was an internet issue.
Anyways, I also suggested this, so obviously I'd agree with the idea. You'd really need overwhelming proof of cheating/drophacking to have someone end up on this list though.
Anyways, I also suggested this, so obviously I'd agree with the idea. You'd really need overwhelming proof of cheating/drophacking to have someone end up on this list though.
Create a blacklist of (confirmed) cheaters.
It's a good idea in my opinion. But then there will be a bunch of negativity on this site... Keep that in mind.
My AoE3 YouTube channel: https://www.youtube.com/c/MCJimAgeofEmpiresIII
My AoE3 Twitch channel: https://www.twitch.tv/MCJim_
Age of Streaming YouTube channel: https://www.youtube.com/c/AgeOfStreaming
My AoE3 Twitch channel: https://www.twitch.tv/MCJim_
Age of Streaming YouTube channel: https://www.youtube.com/c/AgeOfStreaming
- Mr_Bramboy
- Retired Contributor
- Posts: 8219
- Joined: Feb 26, 2015
- ESO: [VOC] Bram
- Location: Amsterdam
Create a blacklist of (confirmed) cheaters.
This is exactly the type of witchhunting that I want to avoid if there is going to be a blacklist. Record/stream your games so you have evidence that he has done this. Along with the stats page indicating that you should''ve won, this is enough evidence for a blacklist.bhcata wrote:Better add .. to that list huh. I don''t know why they removed my posts? It was clear he cheated. Even he got pr / points on ELO rating with 104 vills made and 104 vills killed. He said he would drop, did drop, messaged me to laugh about it - all of this was screenshot, so why not leave on this forum?
Why is he still in the tournament able to play? Ban him. He''s a proven cheater.
Create a blacklist of (confirmed) cheaters.
The mods have stated many times that they do not like this kind of stuff on here. I'm not against said list, but it will bring about much negativity. inb4 locked thread
Check out my Custom Map Workshop here!
http://eso-community.net/viewtopic.php?p=98718#top
http://eso-community.net/viewtopic.php?p=98718#top
- Mr_Bramboy
- Retired Contributor
- Posts: 8219
- Joined: Feb 26, 2015
- ESO: [VOC] Bram
- Location: Amsterdam
Create a blacklist of (confirmed) cheaters.
I''d like a reasoning. With good evidence and positive results, why not?durokan wrote:The mods have stated many times that they do not like this kind of stuff on here.
Create a blacklist of (confirmed) cheaters.
I thought a bit about the negativity argument, and then I remembered that we had something at the N3O clan forum. Didnt really bring any negativity about, and even though that was a slightly different form of community, I think it's rather comparable to this community.
-
- Skirmisher
- Posts: 169
- Joined: Feb 27, 2015
Create a blacklist of (confirmed) cheaters.
I agree, good Idea
Create a blacklist of (confirmed) cheaters.
Huh? What do you mean? I did have evidence. I screenshot everything and uploaded it here, but for some reason it got deleted? I can see why if its unclear youd protect someone, but this is obvious and proven hacking of the game to get points. Plus go check out elo stats now. Look at this:bramboy wrote:This is exactly the type of witchhunting that I want to avoid if there is going to be a blacklist. Record/stream your games so you have evidence that he has done this. Along with the stats page indicating that you shouldve won, this is enough evidence for a blacklist.bhcata wrote:Better add .. to that list huh. I dont know why they removed my posts? It was clear he cheated. Even he got pr / points on ELO rating with 104 vills made and 104 vills killed. He said he would drop, did drop, messaged me to laugh about it - all of this was screenshot, so why not leave on this forum?
Why is he still in the tournament able to play? Ban him. Hes a proven cheater.
http://www.agecommunity.com/stats/GameS ... =en-US&'GameID=67c144c3-743b-4122-a188-92c4209d6132&'sFlag=2&'md=ZS_Supremacy
You have everything you need for a blacklist.
Create a blacklist of (confirmed) cheaters.
It's in the works
indeed, we've never liked these threads on the boards here mostly because we didn't want to become cheat-buster central. furthermore, there's nothing we could really do about cheaters. however, given the lack of response from microsoft admins, we're going to look into opening a blacklist thread, with the purpose of keeping all of that discussion in that thread
indeed, we've never liked these threads on the boards here mostly because we didn't want to become cheat-buster central. furthermore, there's nothing we could really do about cheaters. however, given the lack of response from microsoft admins, we're going to look into opening a blacklist thread, with the purpose of keeping all of that discussion in that thread
Create a blacklist of (confirmed) cheaters.
Yeah, I think that''s the best solution. In a way you can''t really prevent the threads anyway, so you might aswell guide them to one big thread.incog wrote:It''s in the works
indeed, we''ve never liked these threads on the boards here mostly because we didn''t want to become cheat-buster central. furthermore, there''s nothing we could really do about cheaters. however, given the lack of response from microsoft admins, we''re going to look into opening a blacklist thread, with the purpose of keeping all of that discussion in that thread
Create a blacklist of (confirmed) cheaters.
I support this assuming that proof is provided in the form of screenshots and videos. If we place people of this list purely on the basis of personal accusations, we risk starting a witch hunt. I suggest that a blacklist thread be closely monitored, and that any unsubstantiated claims be removed immediately.
The function of man is to live, not to exist.
Create a blacklist of (confirmed) cheaters.
It's a nice idea imo and I want help you giving some names but hope notone wants to lock this because it's too important report these cheaters.
Create a blacklist of (confirmed) cheaters.
bramboy wrote:I just got dropped again and Im honestly sick of it. Ive suggested a similar blacklist before but never got a real answer back. My idea is to make a blacklist on the forums with a list of cheaters. I dont want to have a witchhunt, I just want to make people aware of the fact that certain players are cheaters. Of course, there must be evidence (recorded footage of a dropper) which must be submitted to a moderator of the blacklist. Itd also be a good idea to lock the thread so that there wont be random accusations without any evidence.
Thoughts? If this is well organized and not a total mess, I think itd be a good idea.
And for those saying "just pest em lol", I mainly play quicksearch because I think you improve more from playing against random people with random ranks on random maps with random civs.
While I can understand your frustration this idea will not work. There are always more smurf accounts each year (strangely coinciding with the steam summer sale). There are enough droppers out there to fill the pages of a dictionary and your pest list doesnt have that kind of room. Yes its unfair and it detracts from your personal game experience, but you need to resist the urge to "punish" these players. They can simply buy new keys and your solution wont have achieved much. When this happens to you just remind yourself why you are part of this community, i.e. to have fun. Pest the person and dive into the next game. If you spend your time trying to identify all of these people you will be playing less and not enjoying yourself.
Do what I do. Pest the player then hop into the next game lobby and green up! Youll be in a new game having fun and you wont need to switch to decaf due to severe heart palpitations.
- Cheers
"He's just got more stuff, and sometimes just having more stuff, despite the fact you have better positioning or better micro just doesn't matter because sometimes when you just got more stuff you just win the game." - ZutaZuta
Create a blacklist of (confirmed) cheaters.
Email I sent to Steve after getting dropped on stream by that obse guy:
Hey Matthew,
Thanks for the heads up. I'll forward this on to BarbarossaBlade.
-Kieffer
-----Original Message-----
From: DELETED
Sent: Thursday, June 25, 2015 3:42 AM
To: DELETED
Subject: RE: AoM: EE
Hey Steve!
Whats up, hope you are doing well. I am writing on behalf of aoe3 community. There is this pesky drop trick cheater, and I have it on my stream on 6/23/15, http://www.twitch.tv/giveuanxiety/c/6879709
Im not sure if or how you deal with AoE3 at all, but we would appreciate it if you could help us out. Thanks. Also screenshot of another time vs him.
Thanks!
- Matt
Hey Matthew,
Thanks for the heads up. I'll forward this on to BarbarossaBlade.
-Kieffer
-----Original Message-----
From: DELETED
Sent: Thursday, June 25, 2015 3:42 AM
To: DELETED
Subject: RE: AoM: EE
Hey Steve!
Whats up, hope you are doing well. I am writing on behalf of aoe3 community. There is this pesky drop trick cheater, and I have it on my stream on 6/23/15, http://www.twitch.tv/giveuanxiety/c/6879709
Im not sure if or how you deal with AoE3 at all, but we would appreciate it if you could help us out. Thanks. Also screenshot of another time vs him.
Thanks!
- Matt
Create a blacklist of (confirmed) cheaters.
Nice points, I took ''em.bhcata wrote:That''s not the point - the point is if you cheat outside of the tourney and it''s proven (he was stupid enough to say he''ll drop me, drop me, get the ELO, and then message me to take the piss that he dropped me), then they shouldnt be able to play in the tourney.
Mmm... that''s good PR!
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 19 guests