Fixing Starting Crates

Should starting crates be fixed for all civilizations?

Yes
47
57%
No
36
43%
 
Total votes: 83

User avatar
New Zealand zoom
Gendarme
Posts: 9314
Joined: Apr 26, 2015
ESO: Funnu
Location: New_Sweland

Fixing Starting Crates

  • Quote

Post by zoom »

Although I am particularly interested in your opinion, I'm not particularly interested in arguing this topic, now. I will only say that it would definitively help balancing civilizations, significantly.


IIRC, last time we did this, it was split right down the middle. Thank you for your thoughts!
France Kaiserklein
Pro Player
Posts: 10278
Joined: Jun 6, 2015
Location: Paris
GameRanger ID: 5529322

Re: Fixing Starting Crates

Post by Kaiserklein »

Lazy and bad solution
Image
Image
Image
LoOk_tOm wrote:I have something in particular against Kaisar (GERMANY NOOB mercenary LAMME FOREVER) And the other people (noobs) like suck kaiser ... just this ..
Australia Hazza54321
Pro Player
Winter Champion 2020 x2Donator 01
Posts: 8049
Joined: May 4, 2015
ESO: PrinceofBabu

Re: Fixing Starting Crates

Post by Hazza54321 »

its a boring change but it might have to be done. Civs with wood starts are kinda op and asian civs with gold start seem abit shit
User avatar
Great Britain Riotcoke
Retired Contributor
ECL Reigning ChampsDonator 01
Posts: 4088
Joined: May 7, 2019
ESO: Riotcoke
Location: Dorsetshire
Clan: UwU

Re: Fixing Starting Crates

Post by Riotcoke »

Changes the meta too much and makes for dull gameplay.
Image

twitch.tv/stangoesdeepTV
No Flag deleted_user0
Ninja
Posts: 13004
Joined: Apr 28, 2020

Re: Fixing Starting Crates

  • Quote

Post by deleted_user0 »

Kaiserklein wrote:Lazy and bad solution

Read: I play civs that get huge advantage having wood starts and I know the top civs won't have fixed wood starts. Therefore, I don't want the game to be more competitive as random crates give bring me advantage.
Sweden Hawk_Girl
Dragoon
Donator 01
Posts: 419
Joined: Dec 15, 2015

Re: Fixing Starting Crates

  • Quote

Post by Hawk_Girl »

Doesn't exactly make china a boring civ having a fixed crate start..
Image
User avatar
New Zealand zoom
Gendarme
Posts: 9314
Joined: Apr 26, 2015
ESO: Funnu
Location: New_Sweland

Re: Fixing Starting Crates

Post by zoom »

somppukunkku wrote:
Kaiserklein wrote:Lazy and bad solution

Read: I play civs that get huge advantage having wood starts and I know the top civs won't have fixed wood starts. Therefore, I don't want the game to be more competitive as random crates give bring me advantage.
Maybe he likes the variety, even if it's mostly not meaningful (choice-driven).
User avatar
France [Armag] diarouga
Ninja
NWC LAN Gold
Posts: 12710
Joined: Feb 26, 2015
ESO: diarouga
Location: France

Re: Fixing Starting Crates

Post by [Armag] diarouga »

I have to admit that Zoi is actually doing a very good job, by finally asking the right questions. :ohmy:

As most people know, I am totally for fixed crates, and I believe that it would drastically improve the balance. In fact, remove the 200w start for Germany would be the best way to balance the civ honestly.

Most people don't understand how big random crate is, I'll take some examples to try to prove that it is game changing.
1) Let's consider Dutch vs Japan.

A) On a wood start, Japan will get a consulate and a shrine for free, and will start aging at about 3min without treasures.
On a wood start, Dutch will start aging at 3min.

B) On a coin start, Japan will have to chop 105wood, and age at 3min20 because of that.
Dutch however, can age with 14 villagers, that is to say 2min40.

In the end, there's 40-50 second difference in relative age up time between both these scenarios. How is this acceptable? You're 40 seconds slower than your opponent just because you got an unlucky crate start, no wonder aoe2 players make fun of us xD.

2) China vs any civ

We all know China has fixed crates while your opponent doesn't. Thus, sometimes your opponent gets +100f, sometimes he gets +100f+100w and you get the same crates.
Again, how is it fair to start with +100w or -100w, just based on luck?

The biggest issue is still Germany and the TP start of course (yea, bigger than being +40sec faster or starting with -100w), but since experience isn't a normal resource, I can't really explain it, so you'll have to trust me on that.

Anyway, it doesn't really make the game "boring and dull", the only real difference is that you can't take TPs in age 1, which is exactly what fixed crates is meant to fix, as it is probably the biggest balance issue right now.

If people think it's too boring, removing wood start from Germany would be enough for me.
Australia Hazza54321
Pro Player
Winter Champion 2020 x2Donator 01
Posts: 8049
Joined: May 4, 2015
ESO: PrinceofBabu

Re: Fixing Starting Crates

Post by Hazza54321 »

variety is good but maybe somehow make everytime dutch gets a coin start other dude gets wood start and vice versa rather than huge changes in both directions.
No Flag deleted_user0
Ninja
Posts: 13004
Joined: Apr 28, 2020

Re: Fixing Starting Crates

  • Quote

Post by deleted_user0 »

For variety, make some maps start with (known) extra crate and people can adjust their civs according to that in tournament. Variety. Win-Win.
User avatar
France [Armag] diarouga
Ninja
NWC LAN Gold
Posts: 12710
Joined: Feb 26, 2015
ESO: diarouga
Location: France

Re: Fixing Starting Crates

Post by [Armag] diarouga »

Hazza54321 wrote:variety is good but maybe somehow make everytime dutch gets a coin start other dude gets wood start and vice versa rather than huge changes in both directions.

It's still bad honestly. Coin start is the best for Dutch but playing against a wood start (ie free TP for nilla civs) and a coin start (market) is just not the same, and it would be unfair for Dutch.
User avatar
France [Armag] diarouga
Ninja
NWC LAN Gold
Posts: 12710
Joined: Feb 26, 2015
ESO: diarouga
Location: France

Re: Fixing Starting Crates

Post by [Armag] diarouga »

somppukunkku wrote:For variety, make some maps start with (known) extra crate and people can adjust their civs according to that in tournament. Variety. Win-Win.

Yea, Fixing the crates on each map seems better.
Seriously, I would just mirror Germany every time there's a 200w start instead of picking okish MUs on 100w start and praying not to get the 200w start lol.
User avatar
France flontier
Lancer
Intermediate Division Winner
Posts: 630
Joined: Aug 13, 2015
ESO: Flontier
Clan: PLOP

Re: Fixing Starting Crates

Post by flontier »

Fre gonna be very sad, rip 8 huss opening :(
No Flag 5CH3U3R
Crossbow
Posts: 8
Joined: Aug 7, 2019

Re: Fixing Starting Crates

Post by 5CH3U3R »

An alternative way would be to define that the random box could not be of the OP resource type for that civilization. For example:
German random box: food or gold;
Dutch random box: Wood or food;

Another option would be to set the random box as the second best option for that civilization. For example:
German Random Box: Gold
Dutch random box: wood

Still I think fixing all the boxes is a better option.
User avatar
France [Armag] diarouga
Ninja
NWC LAN Gold
Posts: 12710
Joined: Feb 26, 2015
ESO: diarouga
Location: France

Re: Fixing Starting Crates

Post by [Armag] diarouga »

5CH3U3R wrote:An alternative way would be to define that the random box could not be of the OP resource type for that civilization. For example:
German random box: food or gold;
Dutch random box: Wood or food;

Another option would be to set the random box as the second best option for that civilization. For example:
German Random Box: Gold
Dutch random box: wood

Still I think fixing all the boxes is a better option.

Yea, as I said, removing wood for Germany and coin for Japan is enough for me as it fixes the balance issues.
Australia Peachrocks
Lancer
Posts: 506
Joined: Jul 11, 2019
ESO: Peachrocks

Re: Fixing Starting Crates

  • Quote

Post by Peachrocks »

Ironically despite me seemingly being in favour of the random with natives I am pro fixed crates for one simple reason. Certain extra crates are near useless for some civs while others outright change their entire early game.

Randomly being able or not being able to do something in the first moments of the game is utter nonsense. In the big picture it doesn’t add diversity to strategy it conforms it.
User avatar
New Zealand zoom
Gendarme
Posts: 9314
Joined: Apr 26, 2015
ESO: Funnu
Location: New_Sweland

Re: Fixing Starting Crates

Post by zoom »

Could still keep the random bonus food crate, as well, to change the pace of games, for variety.
User avatar
Kiribati princeofcarthage
Retired Contributor
Posts: 8861
Joined: Aug 28, 2015
Location: Milky Way!

Re: Fixing Starting Crates

Post by princeofcarthage »

If you achieve relative balance on a common ground in case say no tp maps or tp maps either way, random crates wouldn't be an issue rather open up multiple gameplay options
Fine line to something great is a strange change.
User avatar
New Zealand zoom
Gendarme
Posts: 9314
Joined: Apr 26, 2015
ESO: Funnu
Location: New_Sweland

Re: Fixing Starting Crates

Post by zoom »

5CH3U3R wrote:An alternative way would be to define that the random box could not be of the OP resource type for that civilization. For example:
German random box: food or gold;
Dutch random box: Wood or food;

Another option would be to set the random box as the second best option for that civilization. For example:
German Random Box: Gold
Dutch random box: wood

Still I think fixing all the boxes is a better option.
This should solve most of the balance issues, but if anything, it just highlights the persistent problem: One spawn will simply be superior to the other, without offering any options in strategy.
User avatar
Brazil macacoalbino
Howdah
Posts: 1305
Joined: Apr 2, 2015
ESO: MacacoAlbino
Clan: 3Huss

Re: Fixing Starting Crates

Post by macacoalbino »

zoom wrote:This should solve most of the balance issues, but if anything, it just highlights the persistent problem: One spawn will simply be superior to the other, without offering any options in strategy.

Isn't it the case with any given crate spawn though?
Image

Image
User avatar
Italy gamevideo113
Howdah
Posts: 1899
Joined: Apr 26, 2017
ESO: gamevideo113

Re: Fixing Starting Crates

Post by gamevideo113 »

It's hard to say. On one hand it feels like fixing crates would take away from the game mechanics, on the other hand it is kinda necessary if we want to achieve the best balance possible.
I'm not against randomness in crate spawns but i think the randomness should be a bit standardized. Maybe give every civ a 50% chance of an extra food crate and a 50% (maybe 30?) chance of a second best crate (different for each civ) like 5CH3U3R was suggesting

So ger has fixed 100w 200f and on top of that 50% chance of food crate and 50%(/30%) chance of coin crate.
I think it would be sad to completely remove market starts or any kind of discovery age variety.
[Some people aspire to be pr30+, some people aspire to have fun, and some people aspire to play 3v3 Deccan.] - vividlyplain - 2019 Who (nationality) rape ?
stupid logic. noob players can say op?
toxic, Insult, Racism ?
User avatar
New Zealand zoom
Gendarme
Posts: 9314
Joined: Apr 26, 2015
ESO: Funnu
Location: New_Sweland

Re: Fixing Starting Crates

Post by zoom »

macacoalbino wrote:
zoom wrote:This should solve most of the balance issues, but if anything, it just highlights the persistent problem: One spawn will simply be superior to the other, without offering any options in strategy.

Isn't it the case with any given crate spawn though?
Absolutely—minus the balance issues.
User avatar
France [Armag] diarouga
Ninja
NWC LAN Gold
Posts: 12710
Joined: Feb 26, 2015
ESO: diarouga
Location: France

Re: Fixing Starting Crates

Post by [Armag] diarouga »

princeofcarthage wrote:If you achieve relative balance on a common ground in case say no tp maps or tp maps either way, random crates wouldn't be an issue rather open up multiple gameplay options

We've discussed that a lot, but a lot of people (me included) believe that reaching a balance between TP and no TP is impossible.
Furthermore, coin start would still be an issue for Japan and India, and you'd still start with +100w against China sometimes.
User avatar
France [Armag] diarouga
Ninja
NWC LAN Gold
Posts: 12710
Joined: Feb 26, 2015
ESO: diarouga
Location: France

Re: Fixing Starting Crates

Post by [Armag] diarouga »

macacoalbino wrote:
zoom wrote:This should solve most of the balance issues, but if anything, it just highlights the persistent problem: One spawn will simply be superior to the other, without offering any options in strategy.

Isn't it the case with any given crate spawn though?

Nope, read my first post.
User avatar
Great Britain Riotcoke
Retired Contributor
ECL Reigning ChampsDonator 01
Posts: 4088
Joined: May 7, 2019
ESO: Riotcoke
Location: Dorsetshire
Clan: UwU

Re: Fixing Starting Crates

Post by Riotcoke »

Would it be possible to make random crate spawns mu dependent? I.e have random crates on mus that are relatively unaffected by crate spawns but fixed crates otherwise?
Image

twitch.tv/stangoesdeepTV

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 19 guests

Which top 10 players do you wish to see listed?

All-time

Active last two weeks

Active last month

Supremacy

Treaty

Official

ESOC Patch

Treaty Patch

1v1 Elo

2v2 Elo

3v3 Elo

Power Rating

Which streams do you wish to see listed?

Twitch

Age of Empires III

Age of Empires IV