Please quote where I compared erk to skirms, because I didnt. And I already said light infantry is equivalent to cavalry why are you repeating same things? The discussion was about weather skirms is a light infantry or not and it is not. I mentioned ERK because someone said lancers dont get bonus vs them so they are not infantry or something similar to which I clarified the difference between Light infantry and Infantry tag.kaiserklein wrote:You still didnt say why you compare skirms to erk, to me this simply means you dont understand the gameanonymous123 wrote:Are you dumb? Doesnt light infantry include "infantry". I did say Musk get heavy infantry tag which skirms dont get which results in musk getting bonus vs cav.
Sure there is the word "infantry" in "light infantry", you did spot that. Still being light infantry has nothing to do with the "infantry" tag ("normal" infantry if you prefer), since light infantry is the equivalent of cav
AoE3 Tier List (UPDATED APRIL 3)
-
- Dragoon
- Posts: 286
- Joined: Jul 27, 2015
AoE3 Tier List (UPDATED APRIL 3)
-
- Pro Player
- Posts: 10278
- Joined: Jun 6, 2015
- Location: Paris
- GameRanger ID: 5529322
AoE3 Tier List (UPDATED APRIL 3)
This is usually called a comparison. I can give you a definition if you ask politelyanonymous123 wrote:They do, But erk get 3x multiplier against cav thats why they do better than skirms. Ranged infantry is any infantry that fires from range. that includes all skirm/muskarchers/mace etc. Musk get heavy infantry tag because they get multplier. against cav. Lancer gets 3x/4x with card bonus against any unit that gets "infantry" tag doesnt matter if its musk/skirm. They are infantry equivalent to cav/goons, They are NOT cav/goons, Also the reason Lancer dont get bonus against ERK is because ERK dont get "infantry tag" It just has light infantry and ranged infantry tag.kaiserklein wrote:No, thats why its tricky. Lancers and falcs have a multiplier against infantry, so if coyote runners and erk were tagged as infantry (cause they walk obviously) they would die to those. Would be pretty absurd for the equivalents of melee cav and goon to die to lancers and falcs... Thats why they are not tagged as infantry, just as light infantry
Btw ranged infantry usually means skirm/bow units, lets say "anti-infantry infantry". Of course musks do have a range, but they arent the same as skirms.[span style="font-size:12pt'"] [/span]
Anyway, the discussion I had originally with you was about what you said, "Anything that walks is classified as Infantry", which is false, not about "whether skirms is a light infantry or not".
LoOk_tOm wrote:I have something in particular against Kaisar (GERMANY NOOB mercenary LAMME FOREVER) And the other people (noobs) like suck kaiser ... just this ..
AoE3 Tier List (UPDATED APRIL 3)
Then go back to eso and try agian, goons suck vs rattan sheild , lancer owns them rattan doesnt have the abstract cav thing so they count only as inf, ligth that is..zoom wrote:Is that supposed to be in reply to my post? Oh boy, youre in for a revelation...tibia wrote:Rattan shield is also Ligth inf, the only thing that realy beats fully upgraded rattans are lancers....
Rattan Shields are light infantry, but thats completely and utterly irrelevant to my point' they are hard-countered by Dragoons just like Disciples are ?? unlike Tiger Claws.
Oh, by the way: Lancers do no bonus damage to Rattan Shields at all.
-
- Dragoon
- Posts: 286
- Joined: Jul 27, 2015
AoE3 Tier List (UPDATED APRIL 3)
How it is false. Definition :The infantry is the branch of a military force that fights on foot. Like I said you are failing to understand how tag systems work in aoe 3.kaiserklein wrote:This is usually called a comparison. I can give you a definition if you ask politelyanonymous123 wrote:They do, But erk get 3x multiplier against cav thats why they do better than skirms. Ranged infantry is any infantry that fires from range. that includes all skirm/muskarchers/mace etc. Musk get heavy infantry tag because they get multplier. against cav. Lancer gets 3x/4x with card bonus against any unit that gets "infantry" tag doesnt matter if its musk/skirm. They are infantry equivalent to cav/goons, They are NOT cav/goons, Also the reason Lancer dont get bonus against ERK is because ERK dont get "infantry tag" It just has light infantry and ranged infantry tag.
Anyway, the discussion I had originally with you was about what you said, "Anything that walks is classified as Infantry", which is false, not about "whether skirms is a light infantry or not"
Do you even read once what you are writing, because you are making yourself look pretty stupid.
AoE3 Tier List (UPDATED APRIL 3)
Oh my... please dont do this. Trust me. Just test both these things yourself and accept that youre terribly mistaken: Dragoons do as much damage to Rattan Shields as they do to Coyote Runners, and Lancers do absolutely no bonus damage to Rattan Shields.tibia wrote:Then go back to eso and try agian, goons suck vs rattan sheild , lancer owns them rattan doesnt have the abstract cav thing so they count only as inf, ligth that is..zoom wrote:Is that supposed to be in reply to my post? Oh boy, youre in for a revelation...
Rattan Shields are light infantry, but thats completely and utterly irrelevant to my point' they are hard-countered by Dragoons just like Disciples are ?? unlike Tiger Claws.
Oh, by the way: Lancers do no bonus damage to Rattan Shields at all.
-
- Pro Player
- Posts: 10278
- Joined: Jun 6, 2015
- Location: Paris
- GameRanger ID: 5529322
AoE3 Tier List (UPDATED APRIL 3)
So if you dont answer to what I said, I guess you admit you compared erk and skirms, which means you didnt understand how the game works ? Thats a good first stepanonymous123 wrote:How it is false. Definition :The infantry is the branch of a military force that fights on foot. Like I said you are failing to understand how tag systems work in aoe 3.kaiserklein wrote:This is usually called a comparison. I can give you a definition if you ask politely
Anyway, the discussion I had originally with you was about what you said, "Anything that walks is classified as Infantry", which is false, not about "whether skirms is a light infantry or not"
Do you even read once what you are writing, because you are making yourself look pretty stupid.
Who cares about the official definition of "infantry", we are talking about aoe man... And in aoe3, light infantry isnt infantry, even if it looks weird, but im failing to make you understand that obviously
LoOk_tOm wrote:I have something in particular against Kaisar (GERMANY NOOB mercenary LAMME FOREVER) And the other people (noobs) like suck kaiser ... just this ..
-
- Dragoon
- Posts: 286
- Joined: Jul 27, 2015
AoE3 Tier List (UPDATED APRIL 3)
Well i didnt compare, its something like situational comparison where you see how 2 things work out against a single thing but you arent comparing 2 things directly. If its not infantry and not cav what it is then?kaiserklein wrote:So if you dont answer to what I said, I guess you admit you compared erk and skirms, which means you didnt understand how the game works ? Thats a good first stepanonymous123 wrote: How it is false. Definition :The infantry is the branch of a military force that fights on foot. Like I said you are failing to understand how tag systems work in aoe 3.
Do you even read once what you are writing, because you are making yourself look pretty stupid.
Who cares about the official definition of "infantry", we are talking about aoe man... And in aoe3, light infantry isnt infantry, even if it looks weird, but im failing to make you understand that obviously
-
- Pro Player
- Posts: 10278
- Joined: Jun 6, 2015
- Location: Paris
- GameRanger ID: 5529322
AoE3 Tier List (UPDATED APRIL 3)
Its light infantryanonymous123 wrote:Well i didnt compare, its something like situational comparison where you see how 2 things work out against a single thing but you arent comparing 2 things directly. If its not infantry and not cav what it is then?kaiserklein wrote:So if you dont answer to what I said, I guess you admit you compared erk and skirms, which means you didnt understand how the game works ? Thats a good first step
Who cares about the official definition of "infantry", we are talking about aoe man... And in aoe3, light infantry isnt infantry, even if it looks weird, but im failing to make you understand that obviously
LoOk_tOm wrote:I have something in particular against Kaisar (GERMANY NOOB mercenary LAMME FOREVER) And the other people (noobs) like suck kaiser ... just this ..
AoE3 Tier List (UPDATED APRIL 3)
i just testet and i found out you are wrong. The makers of this game forgot to put rattan shield as abstract cavalry, i played alot of teamgames where rattan just rapes all since goon only does normal attack vs them..... SO PLEASE go test yourselfe. ( im not 100% about lancer bonus tbh , but the goon has no bonus vs rattan shield )zoom wrote:Oh my... please dont do this. Trust me. Just test both these things yourself and accept that youre terribly mistaken: Dragoons do as much damage to Rattan Shields as they do to Coyote Runners, and Lancers do absolutely no bonus damage to Rattan Shields.tibia wrote:Then go back to eso and try agian, goons suck vs rattan sheild , lancer owns them rattan doesnt have the abstract cav thing so they count only as inf, ligth that is..
AoE3 Tier List (UPDATED APRIL 3)
I just want to let you know how terribly mistaken I am about the Rattan Shield coyoteman tag, which is indeed absent. Neither Dragoons nor Lancers do bonus damage to Rattan Shields and just as is the case with Tiger Claws, the unit is only actually countered by heavy infantry in melee.tibia wrote:i just testet and i found out you are wrong. The makers of this game forgot to put rattan shield as abstract cavalry, i played alot of teamgames where rattan just rapes all since goon only does normal attack vs them..... SO PLEASE go test yourselfe. ( im not 100% about lancer bonus tbh , but the goon has no bonus vs rattan shield )zoom wrote:Oh my... please dont do this. Trust me. Just test both these things yourself and accept that youre terribly mistaken: Dragoons do as much damage to Rattan Shields as they do to Coyote Runners, and Lancers do absolutely no bonus damage to Rattan Shields.
Re: AoE3 Tier List (UPDATED APRIL 3)
Sioux rifle riders can easily shred frances cavalry
"We are kings or pawns" Napoleon Bonaparte
Re: AoE3 Tier List (UPDATED APRIL 3)
Then sioux get more rifle riders
"We are kings or pawns" Napoleon Bonaparte
Re: AoE3 Tier List (UPDATED APRIL 3)
TNT333 wrote:Then sioux get more rifle riders
Rifle riders have the hand cavalry tag and thus are countered by ranged cavalry!
Re: AoE3 Tier List (UPDATED APRIL 3)
Yeah, and completely outranged too.
Pay more attention to detail.
Re: AoE3 Tier List (UPDATED APRIL 3)
BBCode isn't HTML, silly Eddie.edeholland wrote:[img alt="Chart " src="http://i.imgur.com/GvlmCkg.png[/img]
This goes well with my autism.
Pay more attention to detail.
- edeholland
- ESOC Community Team
- Posts: 5033
- Joined: Feb 11, 2015
- ESO: edeholland
- GameRanger ID: 4053888
- Clan: ESOC
Re: AoE3 Tier List (UPDATED APRIL 3)
Gendarme wrote:BBCode isn't HTML, silly Eddie.edeholland wrote:[img alt="Chart " src="http://i.imgur.com/GvlmCkg.png[/img]
This goes well with my autism.
It was at proboards :(
- Aykin Haraka
- Howdah
- Posts: 1016
- Joined: Jul 27, 2016
- ESO: aykin
Re: AoE3 Tier List (UPDATED APRIL 3)
you upped a 3 years old thread
Re: AoE3 Tier List (UPDATED APRIL 3)
don't bump old, bad threads
Re: AoE3 Tier List (UPDATED APRIL 3)
You would have a point if the information in this thread was outdated. EP EleGiggleAykin Haraka wrote:you upped a 3 years old thread
Pay more attention to detail.
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 16 guests